| Platinum | Big Cheese Pizza |
| Gold | The Old Garage |
| Silver | Papi's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Godfathers Pizza |
| Top Pick | Chatty Pizza & Subs |
| Top Pick | Domino's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hanover Pizza House |
| Top Pick | New Orleans Pizza |
| Top Pick | Tender Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ti Amo La Cucina Italiano |