| Platinum | Kettles Back Home Cookin' |
| Gold | The European Bakery Cafe |
| Silver | Brilliant! Bread & Cheese Co. |
| Bronze | Eckhardt's Shell |
| Top Pick | 10th Street Diner |
| Top Pick | Holstein General Store |
| Top Pick | Stacked Pancake House |
| Top Pick | Susan's Deli |
| Top Pick | Tastea Treats |
| Top Pick | The Kitchen |