| Platinum | Amici Pizzeria & Family Restaurant |
| Gold | Joe Tomato's Restaurant |
| Silver | Papi's Restaurant |
| Bronze | East Side Mario's |
| Top Pick | Fabbrica |
| Top Pick | Gio and Fran's |
| Top Pick | Little Caesars |
| Top Pick | Magnone's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | The Leeky Canoe |
| Top Pick | Ti Amo La Cucina Italiano |