| Platinum | Eckhardt's Shell |
| Gold | Williamsford Pie Company |
| Silver | The European Bakery Cafe |
| Bronze | Birgits Bakery Cafe |
| Bronze | Blackbird Pie O |
| Top Pick | Common Grounds |
| Top Pick | Garage 13 |
| Top Pick | MarJennys Cakes |
| Top Pick | Sunshine Diner |
| Top Pick | The Kitchen |