| Platinum | Steven's Bar-Bq Restaurant |
| Gold | Amici Pizzeria & Family Restaurant |
| Silver | Spanky's Bbq |
| Bronze | Sizzlin Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Beach Burger |
| Top Pick | Bigfoot On 21 Caribbean/BBQ Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Fire & Ice |
| Top Pick | Shorty's Grill |
| Top Pick | Ted & Grace's Snack Bar |
| Top Pick | The Red Door |